As a canine behavior professional, Sandra, owner of Parker-based dreamlike4paws, hears a lot of well-intended advice about dog training from other dog owners – and much of it comes from things people read online, heard years ago, or simply assumed must be true. The challenge is that many of these beliefs are actually myths. And when we base our expectations or training decisions on myths, it can make life more confusing – for both humans and dogs.
The good news is that once we understand how dogs really learn, everything becomes much clearer, calmer, and more effective. Here are five of the most common dog training myths Sandra encounters – and what actually helps dogs succeed.
Myth 1: You can’t train an older dog
This is one of the most widespread beliefs I hear, especially from adopters or people who feel they “missed their chance” to train properly during puppyhood. But dogs don’t lose their ability to learn as they age. Learning is a lifelong biological process. What changes with age is experience – not learning ability. Older dogs may have practiced certain habits longer or developed stronger emotional associations, but they are fully capable of learning new behaviors, building new skills, and adapting to new routines. In fact, many adult dogs focus better than puppies and progress beautifully once communication becomes clear.
What to do instead: Adjust your training approach to your dog’s history, but never assume learning is no longer possible.
Myth 2: Dogs should just know how to behave
Many people expect dogs to naturally understand what is “good” or “bad” behavior in a human household. But dogs are not born understanding our rules, routines, or expectations. Sitting calmly at the door, walking politely on leash, or settling quietly when guests arrive are all learned skills – not instincts. When dogs behave in ways we don’t like, it is usually because they have not yet been taught what to do instead, or the environment makes the behavior rewarding for them. Learning requires guidance, repetition, and clarity.
What to do instead: Teach the behaviors you want step by step, rather than expecting your dog to figure them out.
Myth 3: You have to dominate your dog or be the alpha
The idea that dogs need a strict hierarchy and that humans must assert dominance to gain respect is still very common. This belief largely comes from outdated interpretations of wolf behavior that do not reflect how modern dogs learn or how healthy relationships function. When dogs feel threatened, intimidated, or forced, they may comply in the moment – but stress, fear, and confusion often increase. Effective training is not about overpowering a dog. It’s about communication, predictability, and trust. Dogs learn best when they understand what works and feel safe enough to try.
What to do instead: Focus on clear guidance, consistency, and reinforcement instead of control through force or intimidation.
Myth 4: Positive reinforcement only works for easy or well-behaved dogs
Some people assume reward-based training is only effective for calm dogs, small dogs, or “mild” behavior issues. In reality, reinforcement-based learning is how all animals – including humans – learn most efficiently. It is used successfully with dogs of all breeds, sizes, and behavioral challenges. Reward-based training is not about ignoring problems – it is about teaching alternative behaviors that actually solve them. When dogs understand which behaviors lead to good outcomes, those behaviors become more reliable.
What to do instead: Reinforce the behaviors you want to see more often – that is how lasting change is built.
Myth 5: If you punish a dog after they do something wrong, they’ll understand why
Many owners try to correct behavior after the fact – for example, scolding a dog for something discovered minutes or hours later. But dogs learn from immediate cause and effect. If the consequence does not occur right when the behavior happens, dogs cannot connect the two. Instead, they may associate the punishment with the person, the environment, or whatever they are doing in that moment – which can create confusion or anxiety rather than learning. Timing and clarity are essential for effective teaching.
What to do instead: Guide and reinforce behavior in real time, and manage the environment to prevent unwanted habits from being practiced.
The Big Picture
When we step back and look at these myths together, a clear theme emerges – dogs don’t need force, assumptions, or delayed corrections to learn well. They need clarity, guidance, consistency, and a sense of safety. Learning is shaped by experience, and we have tremendous influence over the experiences we provide.
Dog training is not about controlling a dog. It is about building understanding. When dogs know what works, feel supported, and are given opportunities to succeed, learning becomes natural – whether they are a young puppy, a newly adopted adult, or a senior companion who has shared years of life with us. When we change how we teach, dogs change how they learn.
Sandra focuses on helping dogs and humans communicate clearly, develop practical life skills, and grow as a team, including supporting fearful or sensitive dogs through thoughtful, confidence-building approaches. As a Nose Work instructor, she also incorporate scent-based activities that engage a dog’s natural abilities, build confidence, and strengthen connection between dog and handler through meaningful teamwork.
Want to nominate a local business to be featured on Live Well Douglas County? Email us!
